Last Updated on November 6, 2026

Popular supplements like biotin, activated charcoal, and betaine HCl can backfire by distorting lab results, reducing medication absorption, or aggravating hidden conditions such as stomach ulcers. Before starting any supplement, confirm why you need it and whether your medications, upcoming lab tests, or digestive health make it unsafe, and stop it if symptoms worsen.
Key Takeaways:
- Supplements can backfire when an underlying problem hasn’t been found. Betaine HCl, for example, can aggravate a hidden ulcer or gastritis and landed one client in the hospital, and burning is not a reliable DIY test for low stomach acid.
- Choose probiotics by strain and purpose, not by price or the biggest CFU number. If one consistently makes you feel worse, stop taking it and have it investigated instead of pushing through.
- “Natural GLP-1” supplements like berberine and Akkermansia don’t reproduce prescription GLP-1 medications. Berberine can also lower blood sugar and interact with medications, including diabetes drugs.
- Biotin can make thyroid, hormone, and cardiac troponin test results look falsely high or low. Tell your healthcare team and lab that you take it, and confirm whether to pause it before bloodwork.
- Activated charcoal isn’t an everyday gut detox. It binds many substances in your gut, including medications, which can reduce how much you absorb, and it can cause constipation.
- Aggressive liver cleanses can backfire when your body lacks the nutrients its detox pathways need. Feeling worse isn’t proof toxins are leaving, and it’s no reason to raise your dose.

This episode is brought to you by Quell — to help support rebuilding healthy skin from the outside-in + inside-out!
Take $10 off your next order! Use promo code QUELL10 at check out — Get started HERE!
– – –
Key Takeaways
- Supplement side effects aren’t always obvious, especially when you have underlying health issues that haven’t been identified.
- Probiotic potency and strain selection matter, and feeling worse after taking probiotics deserves investigation.
- Supplements marketed as “natural GLP-1 alternatives” don’t reproduce the effects of prescription GLP-1 medications.
- Biotin can interfere with certain blood tests, including thyroid, hormone, and cardiac troponin tests.
- Activated charcoal can interfere with nutrient and medication absorption and can cause nutrient deficiencies with long-term use.
- Liver detox supplements often aggravate toxin imbalances between Phase 1 and Phase 2 detoxification. You have more potential to help your detox potential with nutrients for Phase 2.
- Betaine HCl can aggravate certain hidden gastrointestinal conditions, making it especially important to investigate suspected low stomach acid before supplementing.
Are you sure the supplements sitting in your cabinet are actually right for you?
Maybe you bought one because someone you trust on Instagram raved about it. Or a practitioner recommended it because you had symptoms that seemed to point toward a particular issue.
Or perhaps you read that a supplement could help with your gut, skin, hormones, or metabolism and thought, Why not give it a try?
I get it.
When you’re dealing with chronic symptoms and desperately want to feel better, it’s natural to look for something that might help.
But here’s what concerns me as a clinical nutritionist who’s worked with supplements for more than a decade: Most people have no idea how the supplements they’re taking actually work in their bodies.
And they certainly don’t know all the ways those supplements could potentially backfire.
Sometimes the consequences are relatively minor. You spend money on a product that doesn’t deliver the results you hoped for.
Other times, the supplement side effects can be much more serious. I know because I’ve seen it happen.
One of my clients ended up in the hospital after taking a common digestive supplement recommended by another practitioner. She’d been told she had signs of low stomach acid, so taking something to increase her stomach acid seemed perfectly reasonable.
Except there was something nobody knew: She had a silent ulcer.
And according to her history, taking that supplement aggravated the situation so severely that she ended up hospitalized.
That’s not a story I share to scare you away from supplements. I use supplements in my clinical practice all the time!
But there’s a HUGE difference between choosing a supplement because it’s popular and choosing one because you understand what your body actually needs.
So let’s talk about six popular supplements that deserve a closer look, the problems they can potentially cause, possible supplement risks, and what I recommend considering instead.
Or, listen on your favorite app: iTunes (Apple Podcasts) | Spotify | Stitcher | TuneIn | Subscribe on Android
In This Episode:
- Why popular supplements can cause problems even when someone else swears by them
- The probiotic mistake that could leave you disappointed with your results
- Why “natural GLP-1” supplements don’t necessarily deliver what their marketing promises
- How biotin can interfere with blood tests you’re relying on for answers
- Why activated charcoal isn’t something to take casually for gut detox
- What most liver cleanses overlook about your body’s detoxification processes
- The digestive supplement that preceded my client’s hospitalization, and why I urge caution with it
Quotes
“A supplement marketed as a “natural GLP-1” isn’t equivalent to a prescription GLP-1 medication.”
“Increasing stomach acidity may aggravate an existing ulcer or inflamed stomach lining (gastritis).”
Links
Use code POD15 to get 15% off your next order at Quellshop.com
Healthy Skin Show ep. 075: Why Biotin Can Mess Up Your Labs (Big Time)
Healthy Skin Show ep. 177: Liver Detox – Skin Rash Connection, Part 1
Does activated charcoal interact with medication?
FDA Reminds Clinicians About Biotin Interference With Troponin Tests
FDA list of troponin assays subject to biotin interference

431: 6 Popular Supplements That Can Backfire (One Sent My Client to the Hospital) {FULL TRANSCRIPT}
Why Supplement Side Effects Aren’t Always What You Expect
There’s something I wish more people understood about supplements.
Two people can have the same diagnosis and need completely different support.
Let’s say you and someone you follow online both have eczema, Hashimoto’s, or digestive symptoms.
You might assume that because a particular supplement helped them, it could help you too.
But the diagnosis doesn’t tell you everything happening underneath the surface.
Your nutritional status, medical history, medications, gut health, and other underlying factors may be completely different.
And those differences matter.
Sometimes a supplement simply doesn’t help because it isn’t addressing the issue that’s actually driving your symptoms.
But sometimes it creates a new problem…yes, there are supplements that can make you sick.
That’s why I don’t think supplement shopping should be a popularity contest.
Before adding something new to your routine, you should understand what it’s intended to do, what it could interfere with, and whether it makes sense for YOUR situation.
With that in mind, let’s start with something that’s probably sitting in a lot of kitchen cabinets right now.

1. Low-Dose Probiotics: Are You Getting What You Think You’re Paying For?
Probiotics are everywhere.
You can find them at grocery stores, pharmacies, health food stores, and all over the internet.
And if you’ve ever compared probiotic products, you’ve probably noticed how dramatically the prices vary. It’s tempting to choose the cheapest option or assume that a higher number of colony-forming units (CFUs) automatically means you’re getting a better product.
But probiotic selection isn’t quite that simple.
In my clinical practice, I often consider multi-strain bacterial probiotics in the range of approximately 15 to 50 billion CFUs per serving. For certain clients whose testing suggests a significant need for microbial support, I may consider different formulations or higher amounts.
But there’s an important distinction here: More CFUs doesn’t automatically mean a probiotic is more effective.
The strains, formulation, quality, and reason you’re taking it matter enormously. Some probiotics have been studied at substantially lower doses, and different organisms don’t necessarily follow the same dosing conventions.
For example, Saccharomyces boulardii is a beneficial yeast rather than a bacterial probiotic, so it shouldn’t be evaluated using exactly the same assumptions as a multi-strain bacterial formula.
What if probiotics make you feel worse?
This is something I want you to pay attention to.
If taking a probiotic consistently makes you feel sick or noticeably worsens your symptoms, don’t assume you simply need to push through.
Stop taking it and discuss the reaction with a qualified practitioner. There may be something else happening in your gut that needs to be investigated. And simply buying a stronger probiotic may not solve that problem.
My takeaway: Choose probiotics based on the specific organisms and purpose, not just the price or the biggest CFU number on the label.

2. “Natural GLP-1” Supplements: Are They Really Comparable to Medication?
You’ve probably seen supplements marketed as natural alternatives to GLP-1 medications. Two popular examples are berberine and Akkermansia probiotic products.
And I understand why these products get attention.
Prescription GLP-1 medications can be expensive, and their potential side effects make some people understandably hesitant. So when someone suggests that a supplement might offer similar benefits without needing a prescription, that sounds appealing.
But here’s the problem: A supplement marketed as a “natural GLP-1” isn’t equivalent to a prescription GLP-1 medication.
These products don’t have the same demonstrated effects or clinical evidence as the medications they’re being compared with. That distinction matters when you’re deciding what to spend your money on.
What about Akkermansia?
In my clinical experience, I’ve seen some clients report feeling fuller while taking Akkermansia products.
However, I haven’t consistently seen the substantial changes in weight or gut health that people may expect from the marketing.
That doesn’t mean research into Akkermansia isn’t interesting. Instead, I wouldn’t assume that buying an Akkermansia supplement will produce the outcomes associated with prescription GLP-1 treatment.
Is berberine different?
Berberine is a little different because it does have properties that can be useful in certain circumstances.
I’ve used it in my practice to support blood sugar management and as part of targeted gut protocols because of its antimicrobial activity.
But more isn’t always better. Berberine can lower blood sugar and interact with medications, including diabetes medications. It’s also generally avoided during pregnancy. (Read more on the contraindications of berberine HERE.)
And because it has antimicrobial properties, using it indiscriminately or at excessive doses may have unintended effects on your gut microbiome.
This is where my Goldilocks approach comes in:
- You don’t want too much
- You don’t want too little
- You want an appropriate intervention for the issue you’re actually dealing with
My takeaway: Don’t buy berberine or Akkermansia expecting a natural version of a GLP-1 prescription. If berberine is appropriate, use it for a clearly defined reason and with guidance that accounts for your medications and health history.

3. Biotin: The Hair, Skin + Nail Supplement That Can Distort Your Lab Results
This one surprises a LOT of people.
Biotin is commonly found in supplements marketed for hair growth, stronger nails, and healthier skin. It’s also added to some multivitamins, protein powders, and greens products.
But there’s a potential problem that often gets overlooked: Biotin can interfere with certain laboratory tests, causing results to appear falsely high or falsely low.
And we’re not talking about obscure tests that nobody ever needs. Biotin interference can affect certain thyroid and hormone levels on tests. That means someone taking biotin for their hair or skin could potentially receive misleading results while trying to investigate a thyroid or hormonal issue.
The FDA has also warned about biotin interference with certain cardiac troponin tests. Troponin is a marker used when clinicians are evaluating someone for a possible heart attack. With susceptible tests, biotin can cause a falsely low result.
That’s a potentially serious problem.
What should you do if you take biotin?
First, check your supplements. Don’t assume biotin is only found in products labeled “hair, skin, and nails.” Look at your multivitamin, protein powder, greens powder, and anything else you’re taking regularly.
Then let your healthcare team and laboratory know if you’re supplementing with biotin. In my practice, I generally ask clients to stop biotin-containing supplements at least a week before planned bloodwork, when it’s appropriate to do so.
However, the necessary pause depends on the biotin dose, the specific test, and laboratory guidance, so confirm the timing with your ordering clinician or laboratory. Don’t stop prescribed supplements or medications without checking first.
You don’t need to avoid ordinary biotin-containing foods. The concern here is primarily about supplemental biotin and susceptible laboratory testing methods.
My takeaway: Something you’re taking to support your hair, skin, or nails could interfere with the very testing you’re relying on to understand your health.

4. Activated Charcoal: Why This Popular Gut Detox Binder Deserves Caution
Activated charcoal has become a popular ingredient in gut detox protocols.
You’ll even find it added to foods and drinks to give them a dramatic black color. Which, frankly, I don’t understand. Because activated charcoal isn’t simply a decorative ingredient.
It works by adsorbing substances onto its surface, which is why it has specific medical uses. But it isn’t especially selective.
Activated charcoal can bind to a variety of substances in the gastrointestinal tract, including certain medications..which can interfere with how much medication your body absorbs.
It can also cause constipation, particularly when used inappropriately.
So if you’re taking activated charcoal regularly without understanding what you’re doing, you’re introducing another variable that could complicate your gut health.
Is activated charcoal always bad?
No. I’ve used activated charcoal in clinical practice. There can be a time and place for it.
But I don’t recommend treating it as an everyday wellness supplement or assuming that taking it regularly is automatically beneficial. Timing matters because activated charcoal can interfere with other oral products. And it isn’t something I’d recommend adding casually to your routine, particularly if you’re taking medications.
What about immunoglobulins instead?
For certain clients, I consider oral immunoglobulin supplements, also called IgGs, as a different type of gut-support tool.
They’re not the same as activated charcoal.
Rather than acting as a broad adsorbent, oral immunoglobulins interact with certain substances within the gut.
I’ve also seen them be helpful for some clients who struggle with gut symptoms alongside histamine reactivity, although my clinical observations don’t establish that they’ll work for everyone or explain precisely why someone improves.
One product I frequently use is Histagut Relief IgG. I use it myself, and I’ve recommended it to clients when it fits their individual needs.
One customer, Kayla, shared an experience that stuck with me. She initially tried Histagut Relief IgG and felt it helped. Later, she switched to a less expensive colostrum product, hoping to save money.
But when her gut symptoms and skin issues returned, she went back to Histagut Relief IgG. She described dealing with itchy, scaly skin around her scalp, ears, and eyebrows and needing antihistamines again during the flare. After returning to the original product, she felt it was worth paying more to avoid those symptoms.
That’s one person’s experience, not a guarantee of results. But it illustrates why products that sound similar on paper aren’t necessarily interchangeable.
Important: Histagut Relief IgG is cattle-derived, so it’s not appropriate for people with a beef allergy or alpha-gal syndrome. If you’re pregnant, breastfeeding, or managing a medical condition, check with your healthcare professional before starting it.
My takeaway: Activated charcoal and oral immunoglobulins work differently. Neither should be treated as a universal solution, and your medications, allergies, and individual needs matter when choosing gut support.

5. Liver Cleanses + Detox Supplements: Why Pushing Harder Can Backfire
If you have chronic skin issues, you’ve probably heard that you need to detox your liver. Maybe you’ve tried a liver cleanse. Or a supplement packed with herbs that promises to flush toxins out of your body.
And I understand why that idea is appealing. You want to get rid of whatever might be contributing to your symptoms. But the liver is much more complicated than a filter you can simply flush out.
Your liver needs nutrients, not just stimulation
Your liver uses multiple biochemical pathways to transform and process substances so they can eventually be eliminated. These processes are often discussed in terms of Phase I and Phase II detoxification, along with transport and elimination.
One important point is that many of these pathways depend on adequate nutritional support.
And if you’re dealing with nutritional deficiencies or other underlying health issues, adding an aggressive detox supplement may not be the most helpful place to start.
In my clinical work, I’ve seen people who feel worse while taking certain liver-focused protocols. They may report more skin irritation, fatigue, brain fog, or symptoms they describe as “die-off.” But feeling worse isn’t proof that toxins are leaving your body.
And it’s definitely not a reason to automatically increase your dose.
What I recommend considering instead
Rather than assuming your liver needs to be pushed harder, I prefer to evaluate whether the body has the nutritional support it needs.
That’s the thinking behind P2 Detox Balance, a formula I developed to provide nutrients involved in Phase II detoxification pathways. It’s formulated without herbs or B vitamins.
The goal isn’t to promise a dramatic cleanse or force the liver to work faster — it’s to offer targeted nutritional support when that makes sense for someone’s situation.
And I want to emphasize something: A supplement can’t replace investigating WHY you’re struggling in the first place. If you have ongoing skin flares, digestive issues, fatigue, or other symptoms, the answer may involve much more than your liver.
My takeaway: Don’t assume a stronger liver cleanse is the solution when your symptoms aren’t improving. Understanding your nutritional needs and the bigger clinical picture is a better starting point.

6. Betaine HCl: The Digestive Supplement That Preceded My Client’s Hospitalization
Now we need to talk about the supplement that inspired this episode.
Betaine hydrochloride, or betaine HCl.
You’ll often find it in digestive supplements, sometimes combined with digestive enzymes. It’s intended to increase acidity in the stomach and is commonly marketed to people who suspect they have low stomach acid.
And that’s exactly why a practitioner recommended it to one of my clients. She had symptoms that seemed consistent with low stomach acid, so she was advised to take betaine HCl.
The problem? She had an ulcer that nobody knew about.
It wasn’t causing obvious warning signs that would have immediately alerted everyone to the problem. But according to the history she shared with me, after taking betaine HCl, she experienced a severe ulcer complication that landed her in the hospital.
She subsequently needed proton pump inhibitor medication for approximately a year while her stomach healed. Her experience illustrates why I take the potential risks of this supplement so seriously.
Why betaine HCl isn’t something to experiment with casually
Increasing stomach acidity may aggravate an existing ulcer or inflamed stomach lining, making betaine HCl likely a supplement to avoid if you have these issues. And you may not know that you have an ulcer or gastritis.
That’s why I’m especially concerned about online advice encouraging people to test their stomach acid by taking progressively larger doses of betaine HCl until they experience burning.
Please don’t use burning or discomfort as a DIY dosing test. It isn’t a reliable way to diagnose low stomach acid, and it could be harmful.
I also urge caution in people with significant histamine-related symptoms, including hives, dermatographia, and other forms of reactivity, because I’ve observed worsening symptoms in some clients.
That doesn’t mean everyone with histamine issues will react the same way. Individual tolerance matters.
What if you think you have low stomach acid?
First, don’t assume that symptoms alone confirm it. Digestive symptoms can have multiple explanations, and it’s important to investigate what’s actually happening.
If digestive support is appropriate, I may consider a digestive enzyme-only product without betaine HCl while the underlying issue is being evaluated.
My #1 recommendation is Digest Aid.
But digestive enzymes aren’t a substitute for assessing persistent symptoms, especially if there’s concern about gastritis, ulcers, or another gastrointestinal condition.
My takeaway: Just because a digestive supplement is commonly recommended doesn’t mean it’s appropriate for everyone. Betaine HCl deserves particular caution when your underlying stomach health is unknown.

What I Want You to Remember
I don’t want you to finish this episode thinking that supplements are bad. They’re not.
I’ve used supplements in clinical practice for more than ten years, and I know they can be incredibly helpful when they’re matched to the right person and situation. But I also don’t want you assuming something is safe simply because it’s natural, popular, or recommended by someone you trust.
Their story isn’t your story.
Even if you have the same diagnosis. Even if your symptoms sound identical. Even if they’ve gotten amazing results.
You may have completely different underlying issues that change how your body responds. And that matters more than the number of five-star reviews a supplement has.
So before you buy another product, I want you to ask yourself:
- Do I actually understand what this supplement does in my body?
- Do I know why I’m taking it?
- Is there anything going on with my health that could make it a poor choice for me?
Because the best-case scenario with the wrong supplement may be that you’ve wasted your money. The worst-case scenario is that it creates a problem you never saw coming.
You deserve more than trial and error. You deserve to understand what you’re taking and WHY.

Your Next Step: Explore the Supplement Options Mentioned in This Episode
If you’re interested in the alternatives I discussed, you can explore them at Quellshop.com.
The products mentioned in this episode include:
- Histagut Relief IgG: Oral immunoglobulin-based gut support that I use in my practice for certain clients.
- P2 Detox Balance: My herb-free, B-vitamin-free formula designed to support nutrients involved in Phase II liver detoxification.
- Digest Aid: A digestive enzyme option without betaine HCl.
Use coupon code POD15 for 15% off your order.
And remember, the goal isn’t to replace one random supplement with another. Instead, it’s to choose support that makes sense for your body, your symptoms, and what’s actually happening underneath the surface.

Frequently Asked Questions
What are the most common supplement side effects?
Supplement side effects depend on the ingredients, dosage, medications you’re taking, and your individual health history. Some supplements can cause digestive discomfort, nausea, constipation, or changes in blood sugar, while others may interfere with medications or laboratory tests.
Just because a supplement is natural or widely recommended doesn’t mean it’s appropriate for everyone. Understanding what a supplement does in your body is just as important as understanding why you’re taking it.
Can supplements actually make you sick?
Yes. There are supplements that can make you sick when they’re poorly matched to your needs, taken inappropriately, or used alongside medications or medical conditions that create additional risks.
For example, activated charcoal can interfere with medication absorption, berberine can lower blood sugar, and betaine HCl may aggravate an existing stomach ulcer or gastritis. Even supplements that are helpful for some people can cause unexpected problems for others.
Can probiotics make your gut symptoms worse?
Yes. Some people experience increased bloating, gas, digestive discomfort, or other symptoms after starting probiotics.
If a probiotic consistently makes you feel worse, don’t assume that it’s simply a normal adjustment or a sign that the product is working. Stop taking it and discuss your symptoms with a qualified practitioner to determine whether the formulation is appropriate or whether something else needs investigation.
Are natural GLP-1 supplements like berberine and Akkermansia effective?
Supplements marketed as natural GLP-1 alternatives haven’t been shown to reproduce the effects of prescription GLP-1 medications.
Berberine may help support blood sugar regulation in certain circumstances, but it can also interact with medications and lower blood sugar too much. Akkermansia probiotic supplements are being studied for metabolic and gut health, but they shouldn’t be expected to deliver the same weight-loss effects as prescription GLP-1 medications.
Can biotin supplements affect thyroid blood tests?
Yes. Biotin can interfere with certain thyroid laboratory tests, potentially making results appear falsely high or falsely low. This interference can sometimes create a misleading picture of thyroid function. Biotin can also affect certain hormone tests and cardiac troponin results. Always tell your healthcare team about biotin-containing supplements before bloodwork, and ask whether you need to pause them beforehand.
Is activated charcoal safe to take every day for gut detox?
Activated charcoal isn’t generally a good choice for unsupervised daily gut detoxification. Because it can bind to certain substances in your digestive tract, it may reduce the absorption of medications and cause constipation.
Although activated charcoal has legitimate medical and clinical uses, taking it regularly without a clear reason may create more problems than benefits.
For certain gut-related concerns, oral immunoglobulin supplements such as Histagut Relief IgG may be an alternative worth discussing with a qualified practitioner. They work differently from activated charcoal and aren’t a universal replacement for it.
Can liver detox supplements make skin problems worse?
Some people report worsening skin symptoms, fatigue, brain fog, or digestive discomfort while using liver detox supplements. However, these reactions don’t necessarily mean toxins are being released or that a cleanse is working. Your liver relies on complex metabolic processes and adequate nutrients, so pushing harder with herbal detox products isn’t always the answer.
For people who need targeted nutritional support, P2 Detox Balance is formulated with nutrients involved in Phase II liver detoxification pathways, without herbs or B vitamins. Whether it’s appropriate depends on your individual needs.
Is betaine HCl dangerous if you have an ulcer or gastritis?
Betaine HCl may aggravate an existing stomach ulcer or gastritis because it increases acidity in the stomach. This is particularly concerning when someone has an undiagnosed ulcer or inflammation. While betaine HCl isn’t inherently dangerous supplements, it can have very concerning side effects if used incorrectly.
A digestive enzyme product without betaine HCl, such as Digest Aid, may be an option in some circumstances, but persistent digestive symptoms should be properly evaluated before starting a new supplement.
How do I know if a supplement is right for me?
Start by asking what the supplement is intended to do, why you believe you need it, and whether you have evidence supporting that need. Your medications, medical history, nutritional status, and underlying health conditions can all affect how you respond. A supplement that works beautifully for someone with similar symptoms may not be appropriate for you.
When possible, work with a qualified healthcare professional who can help you interpret your symptoms and testing rather than relying on social media recommendations or trial and error.
What should I do if I think a supplement is causing side effects?
If you develop new or worsening symptoms after starting a supplement, don’t automatically assume that you’re experiencing a beneficial detox or die-off reaction.
Contact a qualified healthcare professional to review the product, dose, timing, and possible interactions. If you experience severe symptoms such as difficulty breathing, chest pain, fainting, or severe abdominal pain, seek urgent medical care.

Jennifer Fugo, MS, CNS
Jennifer Fugo, MS, CNS is an integrative Clinical Nutritionist and the founder of Skinterrupt. She works with adults who are ready to stop chronic gut and skin rash issues by discovering their unique root cause combo and take custom actions with Jennifer's support to get clear skin (and their life) back.





